YAY! Judging is complete! XD
Thank god. ><
Judging this contest was just so ridiculously difficult. >< I really really REALLY had a horrible time trying to decide a winner, so I had to once again enlist the help of my boyfriend ~kethean to help me out with the judging. He knows both mangas (NLMO and GP) really well (being by boyfriend and all XD) and didn't really know who did what picture, so his input was fair IMO. :3
As stated before, judging was based on accuracy (how well you portray the characters), originality (is your entry unique from everyone else's?), story/interaction (does your picture narrate something, and does the characters in the picture work well together?), aesthetics (how visually pleasing the picture is comparatively to your style AKA your skill will be taken into account), and effort (did you try? XD).
Because of the fact that I'm a big sap and I want to give prizes to everybody, I have added a third place prize (runner-up becomes second place) and two honorable mentions.
That being said, onto the results!!
*drumroll*
..
.....
........
..............
....................
................................
........................................................
......................................................................
........................................................
..........................................
............................
..............
....
...
Honorable Mentions
~JennyShort with [link]
Prize: A bust-up, colored picture of ONE character (copic-colored)
Raye's Comments:I think this picture definitely nailed the Halloween theme right on the head. The two witches looming over a bubbly cauldron is just a classic. Rosie is portrayed really well (you can just smell her mischievousness), but at the same time she doesn't overshadow Jenny's character. They both really work well together in this picture.
Nick's Comments: I love the style of this piece and I love the setting. Rosie is perfect as a witch. The color scheme is nice and the shading is well done. It's cool how the light is reflected off the cauldron.
**
Prize: A bust-up, colored picture of ONE character (copic-colored)
Raye's Comments: This picture was so artistically awesome. Even though Celeyo didn't do a full CG like she wanted to, I think toned look and muted colors are a lot more fitting. Rosie is absolutely adorable in her outfit (I kinda want to draw her in the outfit myself XD). And I think the little scenario taking place with Rosie blackmailing Falc into tagging along as her butler is just amazingly awesome.
Nick's Comments: This piece portrays Rosie very well and I really like the backstory for this one (it makes me happy). The concept is well done. The only thing is that I wish there was time for the full CG (as the artist stated in the description). Overall a great piece.
**
Third Place
Prize: A full-figure, colored picture of ONE character (copic-colored)
Raye's Comments: This picture gets major points for effort. There is a full-blown background and ton of characters (even super obscure ones, like Mr. Rat and the basketball). The situation going on is hilarious, and I can't stop giggling at Talori and Melanies expressions. This picture is just a bunch of fun and mayhem.
Nick's Comments: I love this piece. I feel like i'm standing at the door and almost as if i should be fearing for my life. The characters fit so well in their respective "roles". Also, I love that the two comics are placed side by side for this one. It makes this all that much better.
**
Second Place
~Sumomo-Hanako with [link]
Prize: A colored piece of no more than one character with BG (digital, cell-shaded)
Raye's Comments: Right off the bat, this picture gets bonus points for being creative. No other picture had the artist character be an animal, so kudos to you Sumomo-Hanako! I think my first reaction to this picture was "D'AWWWWW!" Seriously, this picture is adorable. If you haven't looked at it, check it out. The backstory is lovely, and having Talori as a black cat and the dog as a witch was just perfect.
Nick's Comments: I love the backstory for this piece. Even though there is no setting, the background of this fits well for a portrait and for the theme. The puppy is so cute and the fact that talori is dressed up as a black cat makes it all that much better. Personally, i'd love to see this as a short comic strip (Raye: Sumomo, you don't have to do that XD).
**
First Place
~Pottercreep with [link]
Prize: A colored piece of whatever youd like with BG (digital, soft-shaded) + youll be featured in my journal
Raye's Comments: This picture really deserves first place. Pottercreep really put a lot of effort into this piece, and you can see that in the composition and detail. Plus, the narration is so well done. Without reading any description about the picture, you know it's a Halloween piece where a little kid gets the daylight scared out of him (poor Ebisu!) while trick-or-treating. XD The characterization is spot on. I feel all together, this picture really brings forth that autumn/Halloween feel in a cute and humorous picture.
Nick's Comments: I was really impressed with the setting and the action going on. I also love how they put Raye's character, who in the manga has ears and is a guineapig child, into costume of a guineapig. That's amazing. And the artistic skill is definitely apparent and fits the theme so well.
**
**
So there you have it! It really does get harder and harder to judge each year. >< Even with the added prizes, I still wanted to do more prizes for more pictures that I thought deserved something more (I guess that's the reason for the participation prizes but still XD).
Speaking of which, as stated before, everyone who participated in the contest who didn't win gets a headshot picture (copic-colored) of a character of their choice!
Thank you everyone for entering the contest! I'm so glad that so many of you did enter (I actually got four more entries than I did last year)! And I also thank everyone who advertised this contest! You guys are awesome! *o*
Here a list of everyone's names. Please tell me asap what picture you'd like for either your prize or headshot-doodle.
1. Pottercreep: Prize - undecided
2. Sumomo-Hanako: Prize - Aminta
3. xTRINOx: Prize - Toumeya
4. Celeyo: Prize - Panda
5. JennyShort: Prize - Disney girl
6. Keicea: Headshot - Daeva
7. KiryAngle: Headshot - undecided
8. Semiblonde: Headshot - Joe Jonas
9. VampiricKitten: Headshot - Karla
10. TheDarkDeath: Headshot -FMA character
11. Xiori: Headshot - Royalty
12. ArcaneLucidity: Headshot - undecided
13. p5ych0turtl3: Headshot - Roxana
14. Bodici22: Headshot - Katie
15. Loki-lou: Headshot - Zarzamora
16. Chen-san: Headshot - Alani
17. Broken-chan: Headshot - undecided
18. Selfia: Headshot - Unnamed character
Commission Status: OPEN ![]()
Kiriban: 70,000




































